Gimmickry over 300 deaths of workers
With political gimmickry on display, the interior minister Rehman Malik, a real joker, outwitted all his colleagues saying he suspects terrorism. This is a desperate attempt to divert attention from the crimes jointly committed by the PPP and ML(N) governments
On September 14, a smiling President Asif Zardari, escorted by a large caravan arrived at Lahore’s Mao Hospital. Waving to his sycophants, he entered the hospital to enquire after the health of workers injured in a factory fire on September 11. The inferno claimed the lives of 27 other workers. At the time of writing not a single Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) leader has visited the gutted factory or the bereaved families.
The 10-minute presidential visit to the Mao Hospital was a knee-jerk response to the visit of Nawaz Sharif to the Karachi factory where over 300 workers died on the same day in a similar incident. Nawaz Sharif who heads Muslim League [Nawaz faction] is the president’s main rival. Whereas Nawaz Sharif announced Rupees 300,000 compensation for every worker killed in the Karachi fire on behalf of the Punjab government, President Zardari offered only flowers to the five injured workers. The Punjab province is ruled by Muslim League [Nawaz] while PPP runs the Sindh province. Lahore is Punjab’s capital while Karachi is Sindh’s capital.
In the initial three days following the worst industrial accident in Pakistan’s history, routine condolence messages from these two major leaders were reported in the media. Once Nawaz Sharif landed Sindh, President Zardari dashed to Lahore.
The PPP and Muslim League traded accusations, each accusing the other of negligence. In fact there have been no factory inspections in the last four years. Mills and factories have literally become concentration camps.
Under the Musharraf dictatorship, Punjab chief minister Pervez Ilahi banned labour inspections across the province.
The Muslim League government in Punjab did not lift this ban on inspections until a pharmaceutical factory in Lahore caught fire on 4th January 2012. Twenty-seven workers were burnt to death. Trade unions had been demanding an end to the ban long before the January 4 fire at the Lahore factory. But even though the ban was lifted, no practical steps were taken by the Labour Department. (Ironically, Pervez Ilahi of Pakistan Muslim League [Q] who accompanied President Zardari during his hospital visit is presently the country’s deputy prime minister.)
The situation was even more miserable in the Sindh province where the PPP and its ally, MQM, were in power. Here there was not a ban on factory inspections. But in practice, inspections were almost impossible.
Meanwhile these incidents are the topic of talk shows on several TV channels. PPP leaders are pitched against the Muslim League stalwarts. A blame game goes on for an hour on the TV screens. Nobody points out that the trade unions and the labour leaders have been demanding labour inspections for years. These tragedies could have been averted had the labour laws on safety been mandated as a result of factory inspections.
With political gimmickry on display, the interior minister Rehman Malik, a real joker, has outwitted all his colleagues saying he suspects terrorism. This is a desperate attempt to divert attention from the crimes jointly committed by the PPP and Muslim League governments.
Commercial media lends Rehman Malik a helping hand. Certain anchor persons spread the rumour that the factory bosses in Karachi were asked to pay extortion money (bhatta). It is rumoured that the fire might have been a result of mischief on the part of gangsters when the bosses refused to pay extortion money.
Apart from the rich politicians and commercial media, the judiciary has also entered the fray to rescue the class judges always protect. The factory owners influenced the Sindh High Court, Larkana bench in their favour .The court granted them the so-called protective bail for eight days.
The fact that “Faisalabad 6” [six textile workers accused of arson at a factory] were collectively sentenced to 590 years of jail terms reveals the real class character of the judiciary. In the so-called arson incident nobody was killed. These six workers were not granted bail. It is important to point out that the bosses went to Larkana bench, the home town of Bhutto, instead of Karachi.
Ordinary people of Pakistan are shocked over the incident. There is great sympathy for the workers who lost their lives. We must build a genuine movement for decent wage and working conditions for the industrial working class. The twin-tragedy on 9/11 is a wakeup call, yet again.
![]() |
Farooq Tariq is spokesperson for Labour Party Pakistan. Email: This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it |





Comments
I read you article, picturing Mr. Zaradri in so many shades. The picture is not complete. With our permission, I am giving it a new hue and ting.
Should we weep over the legacy of Mr. Bhutto and Zia, or abuse our fate who gave us these two great plagues to weaken the muscles of the nation, and make it frustrated.
Zardari is more Machiavellian than Machiavelli, Zardari Zindha bad., long live Zardari, long live Pakistan.
He is unique in the art of hoodwinking and duping the most seasoned and veteran persons in the domain of politics and grabbling power politics by hook or crook: by murder, favours, cheat etc.
1. He very roguishly and cunningly removed his rival, Murtaza Bhutto who was the real inheritor of Mr. Bhutto’s popularity among the public of Pakistan.
2. He got Mrs. Nusrat Bhutto away from politics by removing her from the chairmanship of PPP though Benazir Zardari. She entrapped her wife by the intoxication of huge deposits in Swiss banks. He was adept in luring, and allured successfully the most educated lady.
3. His most outstanding and remarkable sneakiness was exhibited in his success to beat down one of the most reasoned and veteran political leader in Pakistan, Mr. Nawaz Sharif., who was also well known in the art of showing sleight of hands in politics.
4. Whenever he felt ‘pressure’ on him due to some calamity or fall out of his misdeeds, he used his Machiavellian brain and successfully diverted the attention of the public toward some other direction by creating some ugly phenomenon: when he realized that on the event of Osama bin Ladhum, there was probability of absconding of his chair he wrote to American to save him and get his services secured and was successful by engaging high profile military positions with Americans.
5. Now when he found he is being screwed by Apex court, by big rallies against his unprecedented corruption, steep surge of prices of all items, Haj scandal, dismissal of appeal for review of Apex court order to write Swiss bank authority, he conspired with Americans to attack on the military posts to divert the attention of the public to another more vital problem.
I fully agree with honourable Mr. Qadir, scientist, to award him Doctorate Degree in the art of Machiavellianis m. He fully merits this honour. And depriving him of this eminence we are doing injustice with him. The true son of Machiavelli, Zindha bad. Let us chant some words of applause for him and say, Zardari Zindha bad, long live Zardari, long live Pakistan.
……………………………………… ……………………………………… ………………………